The Best Wet Cat Food

I’ve compiled a list of the best top-rated wet cat foods here and also a list of the worst foods you should avoid.

It is important for cats to get water with their food for optimal health. Wet food is the easiest way to do this. It is also perfect for cat owners who can’t or won’t feed a raw diet. An all-wet food diet is the next best thing.

Wet cat foods are 70-80% water. This is great for their kidneys and urinary tract. Cats generally don’t chug a lot of water and if they’re healthy, they shouldn’t. They are meant to be eating prey animals (like mice and rabbits) and not dry kibble. A fresh mouse carcass contains about 70% moisture.

Many cat caretakers will ask their veterinarian for recommendations on foods. This is not a bad thing, but in my experience vets do not get very much training on nutrition. The education they do get comes from the big-name brands that make prescription diets (Science Diet, Purina, Royal Canin). At least 3 vets I’ve worked with over the years have told me this.

Also, most people don’t know this, but some people have intellectual laziness. Even some highly educated professionals do. I know vets who don’t want to own any pets.

I know vets who will not spend a moment of their precious time outside of work researching pet foods or nutrition or raw diets. But people will trust them no matter what they say simply because they went to vet school.

At least most vets are recommending wet food for cats these days. This is going in the right direction.

I feed my cats mostly raw; however there are a couple of reasons why I still also feed wet food. An all-raw diet can get expensive if you buy pre-made (like I do) especially for multiple cats.

I have been feeding raw for about 10 years now, and there are times when I forget to thaw it out or forget that I used up the last of it and need to buy more. Those are the times when it’s really handy to have canned food on hand.

To save us all time, I have listed below the best wet cat foods and where you can buy them online. There is a short list of budget options at the end. These are all foods I either currently have in my cupboards or have used in the past.

I still work full-time as a vet tech, so I’m not able to investigate every food in existence but I will try to!

There are thousands of different cat foods on the market, so keeping up with the industry could certainly be a full-time job for somebody.

If there is a food or brand you don’t see on the list, it is because it probably did not meet my standards or contains something that I feel is not beneficial for a cat.

The Grading Criteria

These are my simple requirements for a food to make the list:

  • Grain free
  • Dairy free
  • Carrageenan free
  • Under 10 % carbohydrates
  • Real meat is the first ingredient

It should be easy for a food to make the list- but keep in mind pet food manufacturers just make whatever they want to sell you and market it so that it sounds like what is in the can is healthy.

The ideal diet for an obligate carnivore is simple: protein, fat, moisture, vitamins, minerals. No fillers. With the foods on this list, you can be confident you’re feeding the highest quality wet food possible.

As a species, they are a bit different than dogs & humans when it comes to digestion. Cats cannot properly digest and metabolize grains & starches. I try to avoid legumes, which are a popular filler these days. Legumes include: soy, peas, lentils, chickpeas, garbanzo beans, etc.

They have a short gastrointestinal tract compared to other animals. They do not produce amylase in their saliva, so they do not taste sweetness.

Their bodies convert protein into glucose (gluconeogenesis) so they don’t have a dietary requirement for carbs or sugar.

Meat should always be the first ingredient- animal protein is better for them than plant protein. Grains & vegetables do not provide complete proteins.

There are some essential amino acids their bodies cannot produce so they need to get those from animal sources. Meat & eggs provide complete proteins and other valuable nutrients which are essential for cats.

Cats cannot convert beta-carotene into vitamin A. They need preformed vitamin A from another animal. Liver is a great source of vitamin A, vitamin C, omega 6 fatty acids, choline, selenium and other nutrients.

Cats can only get arachidonic acid from meat.

The majority of cats & dogs are lactose intolerant after infancy which can cause vomiting and/or diarrhea. Dairy is contraindicated if your cat is on any type of tetracycline antibiotic. Dairy is now being added to many pet foods- yep wet, dry, and even raw- and that is not always stated on the front of the label- you MUST read the ingredient list.

Carrageenan is commonly used as thickener in pet foods. It has been linked to IBD- it causes gastrointestinal inflammation. This is what is used to induce inflammation in laboratory animals to test the effectiveness of anti-inflammatory drugs.

It is best to just avoid this ingredient altogether. Check the ingredient lists on both pet and human foods as it is commonly found in dairy alternatives and other processed foods. There are alternatives to this ingredient, which is why you often see carob bean gum, guar gum and/or xanthan gum in wet foods.

By they way, almost all of the prescription pet foods contain carrageenan.

Another thing to look out for is preservatives.

Do not ever buy a food that lists ethoxyquin, BHA, BHT, or TBHQ on the ingredient list. Those are synthetic preservatives that have natural safer alternatives.  You might see mixed tocopherols, vitamin E, citric acid, or rosemary extract at the end of the ingredient list. Those are fine.

I personally prefer not to buy foods with plant oils, but they are now included in almost every cat food these days.  If everything else about the food is legit, I don’t waste time worrying about plant oils.

Note: cat foods in pouches will usually always be higher than 10% carbs and were not even considered for this list

Our Top Rated Choices

Hounds & Gatos Grain Free (paté)

The Original Paleolithic Diet

Game bird 

Chicken

Turkey & Turkey Liver

Duck

Lamb & Lamb Liver

Pork

Beef

American Rabbit; Rabbit

Salmon

Wild Calling (paté)

Cabin Fever Chicken

Inland Waters Duck

Trot N Tommy Turkey

Cowabunga Beef

Jumping Salmon

Dr. Elsey’s CleanProtein (paté)

Clean Protein Grain Free Chicken Recipe Paté (contains shellfish)

Clean Protein Grain Free Turkey Recipe Paté (contains shellfish)

Clean Protein Grain Free Whitefish Recipe Paté (contains shellfish)

Clean Protein Grain Free Beef Recipe Paté (contains shellfish)

Evo 95% (paté)

Evo 95 Duck Recipe in Gravy

Sheba Perfect Portions (paté)

Savory Chicken Entree & Roasted Turkey Entree

Tiki Cat (shredded/chunks)

Succulent Chicken Puka Puka Luau in Chicken Consommé

Succulent Chicken Koolina Luau with Egg in Chicken Consommé

Weruva (shredded/chunks)

Paw Lickin’ Chicken with Chicken in Gravy

Quick & Quirky with Chicken and Turkey in Gravy

Cats in the Kitchen cans

 

Hounds & Gatos

Hounds & Gatos Game bird paté

Hounds & Gatos Game bird is one of many protein focused flavors. This contains 4 proteins: turkey, duck, Guinea fowl and quail.

One of the most trusted pet food brands around. They are the original Paleolithic diet company. They only produce canned food for dogs and cats- no dry! This company really understands what a species-appropriate diet should be for cats. They only use animal ingredients- never plants.

I appreciate a brand that makes life easy for me. I know I can just quickly run into the store and grab some Hounds & Gatos and I’ll be giving my cats safe, low carb high quality canned food.

Each batch of their food is DNA tested to ensure that the type of animal(s) that is stated on the label is what is actually in the can. No other companies that I know of do this.

Their foods are always free of grains, carrageenan, byproducts and fillers. All cans are BPA-free. The food is canned by Performance Pet Products in Mitchell, South Dakota.

Made in the USA with meat sourced from the USA.  The lamb comes from New Zealand. They would never use any ingredients from China or Asia.

You can find Hounds & Gatos in the USA and Canada.  It can be difficult to find this brand in stores, unless you have an independent pet store near you like Bentley’s Pet Stuff. It is not sold at Petco or Petsmart. Shop for Hounds & Gatos on Amazon.

The only potential issue I can find is that they have a lot of different proteins in some of their foods. For example, there are two different rabbit formulas this brand makes, and one of the rabbit recipes contains 6 different proteins: rabbit, quail, duck, turkey, pork, lamb. The other rabbit recipe only contains rabbit.

Some cats are extremely sensitive and can only handle one, maybe 2 different proteins in one meal.

Also, fish is one of the top 2 food allergens and is often found mixed with chicken or beef or other meats. I don’t recommend feeding fish unless you know your cat is not allergic, or if they are refusing food and starving themselves.

If your cat does not have food allergies or vomiting/regurgitation/diarrhea issues, it’s nothing to worry about.

I mix it with raw simply because most of the high quality pre-made raw foods are quite expensive and I don’t want to go through twice as much of those.

 

Wild Calling

Wild Calling wet cat food

Here is a small family owned company that knows what cats (and dogs) crave: meat. Their canned foods contain 96% meat with the necessary supplements added in. Wild Calling is made in the USA without foreign ingredients. For them, pets always come before profits.

All of their canned foods are great, but I cannot recommend their dry cat foods because they added starches (tapioca, sweet potato) and legumes (lentils, dried peas). There is no such thing as a ‘good’ dry food for cats so it’s a good thing you’re looking at the list of the best wet foods. The Triple Delight flavor contains multiple proteins & fish.

They used to have a rabbit flavor but I can’t find it so it may have been discontinued. They also had an alligator flavor I bought once. It was soupy and very orange and gross looking. One of my cats ate a little of it and I had to throw the rest out. I’ll give them points for trying exotic meats.

 

Evo 95%

My local pet store sent me a letter saying this brand will no longer be manufactured but it is a good food so if you can find it, grab it before it’s gone! They were owned by Mars Petcare who has also discontinued all California Naturals cat foods, some dog foods, and all Innova cat & dog foods.

 

Dr. Elsey’s Clean Protein

Dr. Elsey's Clean Protein Grain Free wet cat food

This line is newer to the market. I have only within the last month seen it available at Chuck and Don’s. This really is an overall good canned food, and a much better quality choice than most of the options at big name pet stores. All canned flavors have a smooth paté texture.

There are 2 reasons why this brand might not be appropriate for your cat:

  1. All flavors contain multiple proteins
  2. All flavors also contain shellfish in the form of New Zealand green mussels.

If your cat does not have food intolerances or allergies, go ahead and try it. Fish is an easy button for pet food companies because they can jack up the protein level without adding a lot of calories or fat. What I especially like about Dr. Elsey’s is the dry food.

While there is no such thing as in ideal dry food for cats, if you backed me into a corner and said, “You and your cats are stranded on a deserted island and you either have to feed them dry food or let them starve to death. There are no other options”, I would choose Dr. Elsey’s Clean Protein. This is the only dry cat food I allow in my house.

Sheba Perfect Portions Grain Free Paté

Sheba Perfect Portions Paté wet cat food

This one passes the taste test at my house. It is a great affordable option. My cats love the texture. It is a perfectly smooth pate in gel. I can hold it upside down over a plate and the whole mass of paté plops out.

What makes these convenient is that you can open just one side if you want to put out a small amount of food, rather than opening a larger can and refrigerating it and then having to warm up the food again before feeding it. The sides come apart. Just fold and snap.

Only the paté texture made the list because their cuts in gravy line is higher than the 10% carbs limit. I have used the cuts in gravy flavors for a picky eater, because the ingredient list on that food is a bit better than the Fancy Feast gravy lover’s.

Another reason this one made the list is because the paté line has about 45% fat and 45% protein. That is very balanced. Many people don’t realize that the majority of wet foods on the market have around 25-35% protein, which is too low in my opinion.

 

Tiki Cat

Tiki Cat Chicken in Consommé wet cat food

Meat is priority in all of their products.  This brand is canned in a facility that also packs human foods. Both Tiki Cat and Weruva make foods with the same texture: shredded meats or chunks in gel/broth. Pretty much all of their canned varieties are good except the few containing rice. Their After Dark line contains nutritious and tasty organ meats.

It’s a great choice for cats who can handle fish since they make so many flavors with fish.

The coolest thing is that Tiki Cat makes new Velvet Mousse-textured pouches and single serving Stix wet treats for cats who love a perfectly smooth creamy mush. The Stix are not completely nutritionally balanced, so those are for supplemental feeding only but they do all have fish flavoring so they’re great to use for cat who won’t eat chicken baby food.

 

Weruva

Weruva Cats in the Kitchen Chicken Frick A Zee wet cat food

Made using good quality meat in a human food facility. They only use boneless, skinless muscle meat that is fit for human consumption. Their philosophy is to keep it simple to fuel the carnivore. Since they understand that the ideal diet for a carnivore is focused around protein, their foods only contain between 1% and 3% carbohydrates. They’ve created their own rap video, which I think is a first for pet food companies.

 

Wet Feeding Tips

You can always add more water to any canned food if your cat likes it soupier. Some cats really like that (and some really don’t). You can also chop up a pate with any kitchen utensil to make it into small chunks.

If you don’t use a whole can in one feeding, the rest can be covered and refrigerated. Using a cover made for canned pet foods is the best option, but tin foil will work. You can often get free plastic lids from your vet’s office.

Before feeding refrigerated food again, put it on a microwave safe dish and microwave it for 5-10 seconds to warm it up to room temperature or add hot water to it.

Most cats won’t eat cold food and if they do, expect it to be regurgitated on the carpet. Any wet food that is refrigerated will last up to 7 days; after that it should be thrown out.

 

The Worst of the Worst- Avoid these brands!

Meow Mix

Chef’s Blend

Alley Cat

Deli Cat

Kit N Caboodle

Blue Buffalo

Evanger’s

 

These are the foods that have a reputation for causing urinary tract issues especially in male cats. I don’t know the exact reason why (I don’t know any vets that do either) but perhaps they have too much ash or some imbalance of minerals.

Evanger’s is on the list only because pentobarbital was found in their dog foods, which is the euthanasia drug used to put cats & dogs to sleep.

That is too bad because they have one canned cat food that is organic that I liked. That food was expensive at $2.99 for a 5.5 ounce can. It really says something about a company when that kind of chemical makes it into their products. It is safest just to avoid that brand altogether.

Notice the first 5 brands listed are the cheapest of the cheap. If you skimp on quality with your cat’s food, you will pay for it in vet bills later.  Even if you have multiple or outdoor/barn cats to feed, please choose foods wisely. No cat deserves to suffer.

Check if the place you buy food from stocks 12 or 13 ounce cans or offers any discounts for whole cases or bulk purchases. Stores like Bentley’s Pet Stuff and Chuck & Don’s have frequent buyer programs and coupons.

At the very least, almost any wet food (except for the ones to avoid listed above) is better than dry food. If you must leave dry food out, supplement with as much wet food as you can.

 

Budget Options

Here is what I would be comfortable feeding to barn/feral/outdoor cats:

Sheba Perfect Portions Paté

It’s always affordable and widely available even at grocery stores.

Purina Pro Plan True Nature Grain Free Formula Natural Chicken & Liver Entrée Classic 

*3 oz cans only* this flavor only* The barcode # is 038100170491. They recently added ‘kitten’ to the label, but this should be fine for adult cats.

The 5.5 oz cans in this line ALL contain carrageenan. The other flavors in this line have grain fillers and crap in them.

Purina Pro Plan True Nature wet cat food

Purina Pro Plan True Nature wet cat food Natural Chicken & Liver Entree

Nutro Soft Loaf- only the carrageenan-free flavors! I don’t understand why this brand chose to add it to some, but not all of their wet cat foods. They have a statement on their website saying they are cleaning up their cat foods and everything will be non-GMO. This is good. But why were their foods ‘unclean’ to begin with? I hope they remove the carrageenan.

Their paté really does have a nice texture that spreads easily with a soft touch. It just looks kinda gross in the photo because the lighting in my kitchen is not that bright.

Nutro Chicken Recipe Soft Loaf Canned Senior Wet Cat Food

Nutro Soft Loaf wet cat food

 

Petite Cuisine

Fancy Feast Classic line only 

The other varieties (gravy lovers, flaked, minced, chopped, etc.) contain the bad stuff you don’t want to see in your cat’s food. The Purely Fancy Feast tubs are a nice treat, just shredded or chunked meats & fish with some vitamins and minerals added.

I always read the ingredient lists of the classic flavors before buying just so I can make sure nothing new has been added that wasn’t in it before. Fancy Feast is owned by Purina so the meat is obviously not the highest quality but the price point fits. You get what you pay for.

Check the price of Fancy Feast on 1800petmeds as they often have discount codes! Who doesn’t love a discount?

 

 

Facebooktwittergoogle_plusredditpinterestlinkedintumblrmail

4 comments

  1. ernst marc says:

    I have a Persian cat myself that is about 9 years old of age. I love her dearly and, so blogs like this really fascinated me the most. I tend to balance her diet with wet and dry foods occasionally. Furbabies with her age need proper caring and concentrated attention.

  2. Jim says:

    Wow, I never put that much thought in cat food before. I usually went with a well known brand, but saw a couple on your avoid list. I can understand why Meow Mix is there, but why is Blue Buffalo? I thought that was suppose to be a good one to use.

    I know understand the importance of selecting right foods, especially after reading about Evanger’s.
    Thanks for the information.

    • admin says:

      Many people are sucked in by Blue Buffalo, however it has been known to cause bladder problems in both cats and dogs; peeing blood, crystals, bladder stones.

      If I can ever find out the reason why this is happening, I will either add the info to this post or create a separate post about it.

      Thanks for stopping by, Jim!

    • Thanh says:

      Hi Jo – I’m so grateful to have found your blog post this evening, and especially appreciate the photos of the foods, as I’m searching for a healthy mousse/soft pate food for a feral kitty (that has been TNR’d, I think…tipped left ear).

      Kitty’s been around for 8-9 months now, and had a huge appetite at first (maybe parasitic related?), but then normalized over the months, to what seemed a healthy/robust/consistent appetite. Recently though, s/he is now skittish and almost fearful to eat any type of food I offer, but especially food that has to be chewed, in which case, s/he’ll take a piece and run off with it to eat far away from the bowl, sometimes not returning to the bowl at all. I’ve offered everything from his favorite minced baked chicken (unseasoned, skinless chicken thighs), to a number of mid-level brands of canned foods that s/he previously gobbled, to baby food (meats only- which he loved until today).

      I really appreciate the time you’ve put into your posts -THANK YOU! Your entire post was awesome – and I’ve learned so much more about brands that have piqued my interest (like Wild Calling and Weruva). I’ve been wondering about Hounds and Gatos and Dr. Elsey’s for this feral kitty, so your photos of the foods and their textures (as well as all the additional information you shared) has been just what I needed!

      Thank you again for the time and work you put into your posts – you’ve helped me enormously!

      Leave a Reply to Jim Cancel reply

      *